4.6
3000+ Ratings
Best NY Pizza (Dale Mabry Hwy)
4.6 x (3,000+) • 1785.3 km • Pizza • Italian • Group Friendly • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
14741 N Dale Mabry Hwy
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"It was the closest and exactly the taste that I was looking what I’m used to from New York thank you so much for keeping the ingredients so fresh"
• Maria U. • 12/24/21
"I've eaten pizza around the globe and this is one of the BEST tasting and quality & quantity of products I've enjoyed. Keep up the great work."
• Fred A. • 06/28/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM
Featured items
Most Popular
- Buffalo Wings - ( 5 wings )$12.58Large Wings (5 piece). Bone in. Your choice hot, mild, BBQ sauce, Garlic Parmesan, or naked. ( mix of drums and wings, no substitutions )
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Cheese Pizza$21.78 • 92% (2347)NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 18" FamilySize Cheese Pizza$22.93NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 14" Medium Cheese Pizza$18.96 • 91% (59)NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 2 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 10" Personal Cheese Pizza$14.36 • 94% (217)Good for 1 Person. Personal Size Cheese NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust. (Made for 1)
BestNYPizza.com - 12" Philly CheeseSteak Sub (SUB ONLY)$16.03 • 100% (4)HOT SUB - Thinly sliced Philly steak melted provolone and Grande Mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, and mushrooms. On a full size 12" Amoroso sub roll.
BestNYPizza.com - Cheese Calzone - Personal Size$15.51 • 100% (3)A Rich blend of Ricotta and Grande Mozzarella cheese wrapped in a pizza dough.
BestNYPizza.com - Meat Roll - Personal Size$17.18Stuffed with meat, ham, meatball, pepperoni, sausage, and melted grande mozzarella cheese.
BestNYPizza.com
Pizza
- 16" Large Cheese Pizza$21.78 • 92% (2347)NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 18" FamilySize Cheese Pizza$22.93NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 10" Personal Cheese Pizza$14.36 • 94% (217)Good for 1 Person. Personal Size Cheese NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust. (Made for 1)
BestNYPizza.com - 14" Medium Cheese Pizza$18.96 • 91% (59)NY Classic Style Pizza- Our Signature Pizza Sauce & Melted Grande Mozzarella on a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for 2 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - Sicilian Pizza$30.98 • 88% (128)Square Thick Crust pizza made with double the cheese, double the sauce and double the dough of a regular pizza. 9 - Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com
16" Specialty Pizza
- 16" Large White Pizza$31.61 • 88% (96)Grande Mozzarella Cheese topped with dollops of Ricotta Cheese and Tuscan seasonings all on a Stone Fired Crust. (No Sauce).
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Meat Feast Pizza$35.58 • 93% (203)Five Savory Meats- Our Signature Pizza Sauce, Grande Mozzarella cheese, bacon, pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, and ham on a Stone Fired crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Margherita Pizza$31.61 • 93% (109)Fresh Rustic Pizza- Sliced Tomatoes, Fresh Basil, Mozzarella & Tuscan Seasoning with a Stone Fired Crust. (No Sauce)
8- Slices. Feeds 4 or more People. BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large 4 Cheese Pizza$33.28 • 95% (199)A delicious rich blend of Cheddar, Provolone, Romano, and Grande Mozzarella Cheeses on top of our Signature Pizza Sauce and Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Veggie Pizza$35.58 • 87% (39)Five Fresh Veggies- Our Signature Pizza Sauce, Grande Mozzarella topped with tomato, green peppers, onions, mushrooms, black olives on a Stone Fired Crust. 8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large Chicken Parm Pizza$34.43 • 93% (44)Savory Chicken with breading and seasonings, Grande Mozzarella and Romano cheeses on top our Signature Sauce and a Stone Fired Crust.
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com - 16" Large BBQ Chicken Pizza$34.43 • 88% (18)Savory Chicken breaded and seasoned, covered in a sweet BBQ sauce and Grande Mozzarella Cheese on top of a Stone Fired Crust. (No Pizza Sauce)
8- Slices. Good for up to 4 or more People.
BestNYPizza.com
Appetizers
Personal Specialty Pizzas
Calzones and Rolls
14" Specialty Pizza
Sicilian Specialty Pizza
18" Specialty Pizza
12" Hot Subs Meals
Dinner Entrees
Salads
Desserts
Beverages
- Rating and reviews
4.6
•3000+ Ratings •
61 Reviews
Kevin M.• 05/03/24The best in town
Patricia O.• 04/19/24very good
Larry Y.• 04/04/24The pizza is delicious and true to NY, sausage was delicious too.
Karen C.• 03/30/24Great
michele C.• 03/10/24Pizza is always fresh and hot! Thank u!
Cheryl M.• 03/09/24The crust is my favorite part. Everything we ordered was good, but the crust was amazing.
Jesse J.• 03/04/24good
Kevin M.• 01/12/24Great food love this place
Bradley A.• 01/08/24Great
Barbie G.• 11/25/23SLIDERS WERE AMAZING!
Edward T.• 11/23/23Great pizza!
Chris R.• 11/16/23Garlic Knots were gooood.
Duane K.• 11/05/23Consistently great tasting pizza.
Kaitlin H.• 10/28/23Delicious. Worth extra money.
Kevin M.• 10/21/23Great pizza love it very much and thank you
Alain G.• 10/20/23Great pizza every time
Kevin M.• 10/06/23Love this pizza the best in town
Anita H.• 10/06/23I love the pizza, calzone, and salad!
Maria R.• 09/24/23Great taste
Alexandra H.• 09/21/23Delicious
Diane J.• 09/17/23A favorite local restaurant
Kelvin L.• 09/09/23One of the best pizza spots in Tampa
Jesus B.• 09/02/23nice under carrige
Matthew B.• 08/28/23the meatball sliders are amazing. their sauce is the best.
BRUNO R.• 08/19/23Buena pizza
Kevin M.• 08/18/23Love this pizza - 4 Cheese is our favorite
Mishou S.• 08/18/23Best pizza in town
Suzanne S.• 07/09/23Best pizza only place will eat
Karen S.• 07/02/23Great pizza
Fred A.• 06/28/23I've eaten pizza around the globe and this is one of the BEST tasting and quality & quantity of products I've enjoyed. Keep up the great work.
Cindy B.• 06/23/23great taste
Jonathan R.• 06/15/23It's as close to NY pizza as you can get in Florida. I've tried most of the others and these guys are the best I've had.
Roiniel S.• 06/10/23Delicioso
Todd S.• 06/04/23Pizza is perfect… every time
Nick G.• 06/03/23The Best!
Marcha B.• 05/26/23although pricey, always delicious fresh ingredients
MICHAEL M.• 05/26/23Delicious
Kevin M.• 05/20/23Love the 4 cheese it’s the best
Shannon W.• 04/24/23Great pizza and Calzone.
Chris M.• 04/10/23Delicious
Jesus B.• 03/25/23consistent
Kevin M.• 03/10/23Great pizza!!!! 4 cheese is amazing
GLORIA G.• 03/05/23Delicious ❣️
My I.• 02/28/23great taste
Kevin M.• 02/24/23Great tasting 4 cheese pizza
Kevin M.• 02/03/23Great tasting 4 cheese pizza.
Jesus B.• 01/30/23good
Jesus B.• 01/08/23good
Suzanne S.• 12/11/22Pizzas are so fresh. Love the crust too!
Letitia H.• 12/02/22fresh, good portion and tasty.
Michelle P.• 08/25/22Best pizza ever in the area!!
Lillian V.• 07/30/22Best pizza in town!!
Jamie C.• 05/05/22Yummy food at a fair price.
Anthony F.• 02/06/22Delicious pizza!
Maria U.• 12/24/21It was the closest and exactly the taste that I was looking what I’m used to from New York thank you so much for keeping the ingredients so fresh
Andre R.• 10/06/21Great and quick
Judith C.• 09/12/21We are New Yorkers and this is the only pizza we eat! It's the best.
Shirley G.• 08/09/21Excellently service quality food
Debbie C.• 07/28/21Best pizza and wings. Just wish the bag the food was in were closed.
Maria V.• 07/17/21Quick and delicious . Such a unique pizza!
Chris L.• 07/11/21very good!
