4.7
700+ Ratings
Bay 34th Street Pizzeria
4.7 x (700+) • 7889.3 km • Italian • Pizza • Pasta • € • Info
x Delivery unavailable
Tap for hours, info, and more
13605 Midway Rd
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"Awesome pizza and wings! Amazing crust! Highly recommend!"
• Marco H. • 05/15/24
"Bay 34 is great. Great group of people and pizza!"
• Luke B. M. • 08/25/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Every Day
10:00 AM - 8:30 PM • Menu
10:00 AM - 3:00 PM • Lunch
Appetizers
- Garlic Rolls With Marinara Sauce$5.50 • 86% (89)4 in one order.
- Mozzarella Sticks$9.25 • 84% (66)8 stick come in a single order.
- Wings$12.25 • 96% (51)wings come in a order of 9. either Franks Red Hot or BBq.
- Stuffed Mushrooms$10.95 • 100% (26)Crab meat, minced calms, and roasted peppers in a pink sauce topped with mozzarella.
- Meatballs and Marinara$5.50 • 87% (16)3 meatballs come in a order.
Salad
- Side Caesar Salad$5.95 • 76% (30)Lettuce mixed with Romaine , Tomatoes, Black Olives & Red onions.
- Greek Salad$14.25 • 100% (11)Fresh lettuce, Black olives. Tomatoes, Red Onions, Cucumbers and Feta cheese
- Side Garden Salad$6.50 • 100% (19)Lettuce mixed with Romaine , Tomatoes, Black Olives & Red onions.
- Chicken Caesar Salad$11.95 • 87% (8)Romaine Lettuce, Croutons & grated Parmesan
- Garden Salad$9.95 • 100% (8)Good for 1-2 people, Lettuce mixed with Romaine , Tomatoes, Black Olives & Red onions.
- Antipasto Salad$14.25 • 100% (7)Fresh crisp lettuce, beef pepperoni, turkey ham, cheese tomatoes, and olives.
- Mozzarella Caprese Salad$13.25 • 90% (11)
- Bay 34th Salad$10.50 • 100% (6)Lettuce Mixed with Romaine,Fresh Sliced Mushrooms, black olives & shredded mozzarella cheese
12'' Medium Pizza
- Medium Margharita Pizza$18.95 • 93% (31)Pizza sauce with Fresh Mozzarella Cheese topped off with fresh basil#2 most liked
- 12''Medium Pepperoni$13.95 • 93% (49)Beef Pepperoni, Pizza Sauce and Mozzarella Cheese.
- 12" Medium Cheese Pizza$12.95 • 94% (86)Mozzarella cheese.
- 12" Medium Florentine Pizza$15.95 • 100% (22)Spinach, tomatoes, extra virgin olive oil, ricotta, and mozzarella.
- 12" Medium Heart Healthy Veg Pizza$16.95 • 94% (19)A healthy blend of mushrooms, green peppers, onions, black olives, tomatoes and spinach.
- 12" Medium Mighty Supreme Pizza$17.95 • 95% (22)A combination of all our meats and veggies.
Meats- Turkey Bacon, Beef Pepperoni,Hamburger
Veggies- Mushrooms,Black Olives,Onions and Green Bell Peppers - 12" Medium Buffalo Chicken Pie$14.95 • 93% (32)Buffalo sauce, ranch, mozzarella cheese, and chicken.
18'' Extra Large Pizza
Pasta
Chicken Dishes
Calzone Every Calzone comes with 1 4oz Marinara
Stromboli Rolls Every Stromboli comes with 1 4oz Marinara
Hot Sandwiches
Kids Mains
Beverages
Extras
Desserts
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•700+ Ratings •
19 Reviews
Marie Jose P.• 06/19/24Love Bay 34th Street Pizza!! Always delicious!
Jason R.• 06/18/24Best NY style pizza hands down!!!
Elizabeth G.• 05/24/24Quick and yummy!
Marco H.• 05/15/24Awesome pizza and wings! Amazing crust! Highly recommend!
Jean S.• 03/26/24Best and most authentic pizza I’ve ever had!!
Jillian B.• 09/30/23That was fire can’t wait to order again
Luke B. M.• 08/25/23Bay 34 is great. Great group of people and pizza!
Edward W.• 07/13/23Amazing food! Fast and great tasting!
Alex D.• 06/26/23Damm good pizza!
Sharon T.• 06/24/23This is hands down the best pizza in town!
Dawn M.• 06/09/23Food was amazing!!
Sharon T.• 05/14/23Best pizza ever!!
Trinity O.• 04/25/23love their food and customer service!
Sharon T.• 04/22/23Near pizza and best people!
Maria A.• 03/11/23enjoyed my lunch very tasty 😋
Eshita S.• 02/16/23The food is always so tasty and fast delivery
Kyle R.• 02/04/23Delicious food, great prices.
Laura C.• 12/29/22awesome pizza
Dirk T.• 01/13/22Very tasty and quick delivery.
