Fillmores Tavern

$$ • American • Bar Food
Opens at 11:00 AM
  • Starters

  • The Whig Wing Party

  • Millard’s Between the Bun Classics

  • Fillmore’s Entree Favorites

  • Mains

  • Sides

Starters

Mozzarella and Tomato Crostini
Fresh chilled mozzarella, sliced tomato, fresh basil, and balsamic vinaigrette.
$11.26
Macho Nachos
Corn tortillas topped with traditional chili, cheese, and sour cream.
$10.91
Golden Fried Mozzarella
An Italian classic, golden fried and served with tasty marinara.
$9.52
Finger Lakes Chicken Fingers
Tender fried chicken with homemade honey mustard.
$11.26
Popcorn Shrimp
Lightly fried baby shrimp served alongside homemade tartar sauce.
$9.91
Tavern Pretzels
Three pub style classics. Served with a cheese sauce, baked or fried.
$9.26
Potato Skins
Baked and scooped potato with Cheddar, bacon, and sour cream.
$10.91
Garlic Bread
Toasted rolls with fresh garlic, spice, and butter.
$4.78
Beer Battered Onion Ring Tower
Three dipping sauces. Served with our breaded and fried Spanish onions.
$8.13
Baked Clams
Diced and stuffed with blend of herbs, spices, and bread.
$10.91
Stuffed Mushrooms
Fresh mushrooms stuffed with clams, herbs, spices, and bread.
$11.13
French Onion Soup
$6.26
Classic Caesar Salad
$9.26
The White House Salad
Fresh iceberg, crisp cucumber, onion, tomato, and diced cabbage.
$7.91
The Abigail Fillmore Salad
Feta, cranberries, onions, and mixed greens.
$10.91

The Whig Wing Party

Five Wings & Soup OR Salad
Tender wings served in unique and tasty finger licking sauce.
$12.91
Wings
Tender wings served in unique and tasty finger licking sauce.
$10.65

Millard’s Between the Bun Classics

The Fillmore Burger
Certified black Angus beef hand formed, club roll, lettuce, and tomato. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$11.26
Black and Bleu Burger
Secret 13 Blackened spice rub, certified Angus, club roll, and bleu cheese. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$12.91
Charlie Chan Steak Wedge Burger
Teriyaki marinated, with sauteed onions, and smothered in mozzarella. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$15.26
Grilled Tuna Sandwich
Brushed with a sesame seed ginger sauce, club roll, lettuce, and tomato. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$16.91
Cleveland Chicken Sandwich
Tender grilled breast, smoked bacon, all American cheese, and honey mustard. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$13.39
Cranberry Chicken Salad Pita Burger
Tender chicken, celery, cranberries, secret spices, mayonnaise, and mixed greens. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$13.91
Buffalo or Blackened Chicken Club
Choice of hot or 13 spiced chicken, lettuce, and tomato. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$13.39
Corned Beef Sandwich
Spiced and slow cooked. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$12.52

Fillmore’s Entree Favorites

Penne Caprese
Penne, plum tomato, basil, mozzarella, wine, and garlic and oil. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$14.26
Penne Ala Teddy
Onion, basil, garlic, parmesan, marinara, cream, and garlic bread. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$15.52
Millards Mac and Cheese
House blend cheeses and noodles. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$13.91
Chicken Fillmore
Breast sauteed with mushrooms, bacon, gravy, and topped with mozzarella. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$19.52
Pork Chops and Fresh Apple
Tender and thick chops topped sauteed with fresh sweet apple. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$22.91
Angus Meatloaf
A Fillmores staple with Angus beef and warm gravy. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$15.91
Angus Meatloaf Sandwich
A Fillmores staple with Angus beef and warm gravy. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$13.52
Shepards Pie
An Irish classics with beef, vegetables, potato crust, and garlic bread. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$14.65
Salmon Saute
Lightly broiled and brushed with lemon and horseradish mustard. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$22.91
Shrimp Fillmore
Shrimp Fillmore sauteed in scampi butter over Fillmores famous crab stuffing. Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$21.26
Chicken Fajitas or Quesadillas
Served with your choice of soup or salad.
$17.91

Mains

The 13 Blackened Angus Steak
Secret blend of 13 spices rubbed on Angus sirloin, pan fried, and served on a sizzling platter. With steak fries and homemade cole slaw.
$29.91

Sides

Spinach
$4.00
Sweet Potato Fries
$4.00
Onion Rings
$4.00
Garlic Mashed
$4.00
Seasoned Rice
$3.00
Over Stuffed Baked Potato
$6.13
Add items to your cart and they’ll appear here.