Cataldo's Pizzeria - New Stine

$ • Pizza • Italian
Opens at 11:00 AM
  • Most Popular

  • Build Your Own Calzone

  • Specialty Pizzas

  • Build Your Own Pizza

  • Side Orders

  • Salads

Most Popular

14" One Topping Pizza
14''pizza with one topping of choice.
$16.35
14" Three Topping Pizza
14'' pizza with three toppings of choice.
$20.00
Potato Logs
Potato logs.
$4.67
Breadsticks
Breadsticks topped with mozzarella, Parmesan, and Romano cheese.
$5.71
Cataldo's Salad
Romaine, tomato, olives, red onions, mozzarella, feta, and pepperoncini.
$4.42
Antipasto Salad
Romaine, mozzarella, feta, and pepperoncini. Topped with salami, pepperoni, ham, turkey, and red onion. Served with Cataldos dressing.
$4.94

Build Your Own Calzone

Small Cheese Calzone
10'' small cheese calzone.
$8.31
Small One Topping Calzone
10'' small cheese calzone with one topping of choice.
$9.38
Small Two Topping Calzone
10'' small cheese calzone with two toppings of choice.
$10.46
Small Three Topping Calzone
10'' small cheese calzone with three toppings of choice.
$11.53
Medium Cheese Calzone
14'' medium cheese calzone.
$10.39
Medium One Topping Calzone
14'' medium cheese calzone with one topping of choice.
$11.70
Medium Two Topping Calzone
14'' medium cheese calzone with two toppings of choice.
$13.01
Medium Three Topping Calzone
14'' medium cheese calzone with three toppings of choice.
$14.31
Large Cheese Calzone
16'' large cheese calzone.
$15.60
Large One Topping Calzone
16'' large calzone with one topping of choice.
$17.42
Large Two Topping Calzone
16'' ae calzone with two toppings of choice.
$19.25
Large Three Topping Calzone
16'' large calzone with three toppings of choice.
$21.07

Specialty Pizzas

The Bronx
Made with bell peppers, black olives, mushrooms, tomatoes, red onions, and artichoke hearts.
$10.39
The Queens
Made with garlic based white sauce, grilled chicken breast, mushrooms, and red onions.
$10.39
The Manhattan
Made with pepperoni, Italian sausage, hamburger, black olives, mushrooms, bell peppers, and onions.
$10.39
The New York City
Made with Basil Pesto sauce, sun-dried tomatoes, artichoke hearts, mushrooms, red onions, and Italian sausage.
$10.39
The Brooklyn
Made with Italian sausage, pepperoni, hamburger, bacon, and linguica.
$10.39
The Chile Verde
Made with Chile Verde, mozzarella, and feta cheese.
$10.39
Sold out

Build Your Own Pizza

10'' Cheese Pizza
10'' pizza.
$6.21
10'' One Topping Pizza
10'' pizza with one topping of choice.
$7.28
10'' Two Topping Pizza
10'' pizza with two toppings of choice.
$8.35
10'' Three Topping Pizza
10'' pizza with three toppings of choice.
$9.42
12" Cheese Pizza
12'' cheese pizza.
$11.16
12" One Topping Pizza
12'' pizza with one topping of choice.
$12.47
12" Two Topping Pizza
12'' pizza with two toppings of choice.
$13.79
12" Three Topping Pizza
12'' pizza with three toppings of choice.
$15.11
14" Cheese Pizza
14'' cheese pizza.
$14.52
14" One Topping Pizza
14''pizza with one topping of choice.
$16.35
14" Two Topping Pizza
14'' pizza with two toppings of choice.
$18.18
14" Three Topping Pizza
14'' pizza with three toppings of choice.
$20.00
16" Cheese Pizza
16'' cheese pizza.
$17.68
16" One Topping Pizza
16'' pizza with one topping of choice.
$19.77
16" Two Topping Pizza
16'' pizza with two toppings of choice.
$21.86
16" Three Topping Pizza
16'' pizza with three toppings of choice.
$23.95
Sicilian Pizza
16'' x 16'' Sicilian pizza.
$18.20
Sicilian One Topping Pizza
16'' x 16'' Sicilian pizza with one topping of choice.
$20.29
Sicilian Two Topping Pizza
16'' x 16'' Sicilian pizza with two toppings of choice.
$22.38
Sicilian Three Topping Pizza
16'' x 16'' Sicilian pizza with three toppings of choice.
$24.47
20" Family Cheese Pizza
20'' family cheese pizza.
$22.36
20" One Topping Pizza
20'' family cheese pizza with one topping of. choice.
$24.69
20" Two Topping Pizza
20'' family cheese pizza with two toppings of choice.
$27.03
20" Three Topping Pizza
20'' family cheese pizza with three toppings of choice.
$29.37
28" Giant Cheese Pizza
28'' giant cheese pizza.
$40.57
Sold out
28" Giant One Topping Pizza
28'' giant pizza with one topping of choice.
$43.95
Sold out
28" Giant Two Topping Pizza
28'' giant pizza with two toppings of choice.
$47.34
Sold out
28" Giant Three Topping Pizza
28'' giant pizza with three toppings of choice.
$50.72
Sold out

Side Orders

Chicken Wings
Choice of five, ten, or 20 chicken wings.
$5.71
Potato Logs
Potato logs.
$4.67
Breadsticks
Breadsticks topped with mozzarella, Parmesan, and Romano cheese.
$5.71

Salads

Garden Salad
Romaine, tomato, olives, and red onions. Served with Cataldos dressing.
$3.63
Cataldo's Salad
Romaine, tomato, olives, red onions, mozzarella, feta, and pepperoncini.
$4.42
Antipasto Salad
Romaine, mozzarella, feta, and pepperoncini. Topped with salami, pepperoni, ham, turkey, and red onion. Served with Cataldos dressing.
$4.94
Caesar Salad
Romaine, Parmesan, and croutons.
$4.15
Add items to your cart and they’ll appear here.