Lisa's Rum Cake

$ • American
Opens at 9:00 AM
  • Most Popular

  • Whole Cakes

  • Cake Pies

  • Cake Cuts

Most Popular

Unicorn CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Whimsical colored yellow cake, French vanilla custard, and bright blue Italian whipped cream frosting topped with cotton candy sprinkle blend.
$7.00
Tuxedo CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Chocolate cake, French vanilla custard filling studded with mini chocolate chips, and Italian whipped cream frosting.
$5.00
Classic Cathy’s Rum Cake
Original rum cake. Yellow cake, non-alcoholic rum custard and Italian whipped cream frosting finished with fresh strawberries and shaved chocolate on top. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$55.00
Caramel Apple Cake Pie
Yellow cake, French vanilla custard filling, spiced apples drizzled with caramel, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$28.00
Sold out

Whole Cakes

Strawberry Rum Cake
Yellow cake, non-alcoholic rum custard filling layered with fresh strawberries and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling.
$33.00
Classic Cathy’s Rum Cake
Original rum cake. Yellow cake, non-alcoholic rum custard and Italian whipped cream frosting finished with fresh strawberries and shaved chocolate on top. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$55.00
Strawberry French Vanilla Cake
Yellow cake, French vanilla custard layered with fresh strawberries, and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$33.00
Tuxedo Cake
Chocolate cake, French vanilla custard filling studded with mini chocolate chips and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$50.00
Rum Marble Cake
Yellow cake with one layer each of non-alcoholic rum filling, chocolate rum custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$28.00
Limoncello Cake
Yellow cake, zesty lemon custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$50.00
Amaretto Cake
Yellow cake, non-alcoholic amaretto custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$28.00
Rum Velvet Cake
Red velvet cake, non-alcoholic rum custard filling, and Italian whipped cream custard. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$44.00
Carrot Cake
Spiced carrot cake, French vanilla custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. No nuts or raisins. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$44.00
Sold out
Chocolate Chocolate Rum
Chocolate cake, non-alcoholic chocolate rum custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$44.00
Strawberry Limoncello Cake
Yellow cake, zesty lemon custard filling with fresh strawberries, and Italian whipped cream frosting. Three layers of cake with two layers of Italian custard filling. Cake message up to 35 characters.
$36.00

Cake Pies

Tuxedo Cake Pie
Chocolate cake, French vanilla custard filling studded with mini chocolate chips and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Caramel Apple Cake Pie
Yellow cake, French vanilla custard filling, spiced apples drizzled with caramel, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$28.00
Sold out
Limoncello Cake Pie
Yellow cake, zesty lemon custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Chocolate Caramel Coconut Cake Pie
Chocolate cake, chocolate custard mixed with shredded coconut, caramel drizzles, and Italian whipped cream frosting topped with caramel coconut clusters. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Carrot Cake Pie
Spiced carrot cake, French vanilla custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. No nuts or raisins. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Sold out
French Vanilla Cake Pie
Yellow cake, French vanilla custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Red Velvet Cake Pie
Red velvet cake, French vanilla custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Mint Chocolate Chip Cake Pie
Chocolate cake, vanilla-peppermint custard filling studded with mini chocolate chips, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Sold out
Chocolate Chocolate Rum Cake Pie
Chocolate cake, non-alcoholic chocolat rum custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00
Coconut Cream Cake Pie
Yellow cake, French vanilla custard filling mixed with shredded coconut, and Italian whipped cream frosting. One layer of cake and Italian custard filling. Serves eight each.
$25.00

Cake Cuts

Strawberry Rum CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Yellow cake, non-alcoholic rum custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting.
$6.00
Unicorn CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Whimsical colored yellow cake, French vanilla custard, and bright blue Italian whipped cream frosting topped with cotton candy sprinkle blend.
$7.00
Tuxedo CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Chocolate cake, French vanilla custard filling studded with mini chocolate chips, and Italian whipped cream frosting.
$5.00
Chocolate Chocolate Rum CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Chocolate cake, non-alcoholic chocolate rum custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting.
$5.00
Carrot CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Spiced carrot cake, French vanilla custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting.
$5.00
Limoncello CUTS®
6 to 8 oz. Slices featuring two layers of cake and one layer of Italian custard filling. Yellow cake, zesty lemon custard filling, and Italian whipped cream frosting.
$5.00
Add items to your cart and they’ll appear here.